I didnt see the play to which your referring, but I think that he is actually pretty good. Hes got a great arm and pretty good range.
He ran in and misjudged the ball and it went ovter his head for a double... should have been an error but mental errors don't count.
He has already cost us a game in extras with defensive blunder... his arm is decent but is no where near Gut's and Guts range is superior as well.